The Ringer
Discover
anything
NFLNFL

NFL Take-O-Meter: Let’s Rank the League’s New Play Callers

Elsewhere in the lead-up to Week 11: The Patriots are having a Hangover From Hell, give Todd Monken the key to the city, and a Meter Writer makes his case for … Mike McDaniel?
Getty Images/Ringer illustration

Pour a little extra brown in your cup and sink down cozily into your seat, because we’ve got a beefy Take-O-Meter prepared today with new set pieces, art zags, and the largest mini-meter in 10 installments of TOM Wellington. Because it’s TOM’s 10th birthday, in internet years (weeks), let’s not think too deeply about his astrological signs just yet and call this cheeky pre-teen Project X. 

You probably have no idea what that means even if you’ve seen the movie, but you have to know it’s going to be a party, so before we clash cups or pass the gnome around, let’s get to know each other a bit. My name is Austin Gayle. Austin, a lot smaller than Texas with no special Powers, and no one calls me Austin. More people call me Auston because my dad tattooed that on his arm, but, like I texted him then when he sent me the picture, my name is Austin. 

Some people call me Gayle, like your grandma, but almost everyone calls me AG, and the A is for effort and the G stands for glue. Email me at takeometer@spotify.com all the names that you’re called, your favorite football team, how much football you watch on a scale of 1 to 5 (read TOM no. 8 for parameters), and two things you’re most thankful for on or off the football field going into Turkey Day. I have big plans for TOM next week, and we’re eating dinner early (Wednesday) for Thanksgiving.

OK, sorry, let me jump on aux and start the party. Hasta la vista, baby. (You’ll get that in the future.)

The Patriots are cursed.

I’ll say it again and again until my career bottoms out in the same season that I make the cover of Madden: Curses aren’t real. They’re made-up like magic, myth, and astrology. Oz the Mentalist is a scam artist, and David Blaine is a brilliant performer with fast hands. An Achilles is the thickest, strongest tendon in your body, not a Greek hero, and it ruptures randomly, without contact from an arrow or anything at all. The exact time, day, and geographic location of your birth are always just three uninteresting facts, completely nondeterminative of your personality or emotions. More than four people are born every second, and the 360,000 Scorpio Sun, Pisces Moon babies born today aren’t all going to be deeply loyal and creative. The New England Patriots aren’t cursed or under some wicked spell, and the players’ birthdays are irrelevant. The Pats are just a run-of-the-mill bad football team battling significant injuries and a gnarly Super Bowl hangover; these kinds of teams exist every year. New England feels different or more down bad than previous hungover losers only for two reasons: 

  1. Almost everyone hates the Pats. The franchise went to nine Super Bowls in 20 years with arguably the best coach (Bill Belichick) and quarterback (Tom Brady) the game has ever seen, and they were caught cheating twice in two dynasties. The NFL made the Patriots forfeit some of owner Robert Kraft’s chump change and a few draft picks for Spygate and Deflategate in exchange for nine AFC titles and six rings, a common miscarriage of justice from America’s proudest cartel. The Patriots cheated, won, and got away with it; of course people hate them.
  2. They (allegedly) cheated again in an irreversible way. Father Brendan Flynn (Philip Seymour Hoffman), in the brilliant John Patrick Shanley film Doubt, analogizes gossip to a gutted throw pillow on the roof: a confetti pop of swirling feathers in the wind that can’t be recaptured. Whether or not Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel and The Russini Report’s Dianna Russini did anything more than hold hands at a romantic adults-only hotel or kiss at a bar isn’t important, really. They’ve both denied the allegations, so maybe we should believe them and move forward holding hands together. But the truth couldn’t even pluck all the feathers blowing in circles around Vrabel and his team now. 

Vrabel is the biggest reason why the Patriots overperformed so much last season. He doesn’t call plays on either side of the ball, but Vrabel was the glue for a bad, inexperienced roster with a young quarterback that made the goddamn Super Bowl. Before the Russini files dropped, Vrabs was a beloved New England hero from his playing days and rapidly approaching legendary status by taking the Pats to a Bowl in his first year coaching the team. But nothing has been the same for Mike or the Patriots since Sedona, and injuries have only been added to insult. 

Vrabel lost his quarterback, Drake Maye, to an ankle injury on New England’s opening possession against the Detroit Lions in Germany last week. The Pats got blown out, 35-10, and Maye could now miss the rest of the season. After the game, Vrabel complained about players complaining in general, not about players on his team. Don’t automatically assume that. He later hilariously admitted that he wouldn’t be able to recognize a locker room problem because he’s never had one, which is exactly the kind of coach who can get blindsided by a locker room problem if he had one. And he doesn’t, of course, but he also wouldn’t know if he did. Anyway, Vrabel’s message to his team of players who aren’t complaining is to say less and do more. You don’t need a Lilith to see that Vrabel is spiraling over lost love, but I sought one out anyway. 

According to spirited research from Lil Tater Astrology in March 2026, the alleged affair between Vrabel and Russini was actually a “capital A Affair” because their Lilith shows that Russini’s Mercury is directly opposite Vrabel’s Saturn and that they have a Mars-Venus conjunction. 

Source: Lil Tater

“[Vrabel] likes that [Russini’s] a romantic,” Tater writes. “He likes that she likes being his affair partner. He gets off on her getting off on their love being forbidden. The risk and the potential to destroy both of their lives is the allure.”

This is obviously ridiculous, and it gets even more so when Tater argues that Russini wanted to be a reporter because she’s a Capricorn and their birthdays made Vrabel and Russini predestined for a “student-teacher dynamic” in the bedroom. There’s no magic, myth, Lilith, or curse to blame here. The Patriots are having what I’m calling a Hangover From Hell—a Super Bowl Hangover crossed with a Year From Hell—for obvious, real-life reasons. Their schedule is harder, their good players are hurt, and their coach’s head is spinning through wind, space, and time with feathers and stars in his eyes. 

Give Todd Monken a key to the city of Cleveland.

Don’t, actually. Should anyone really have a key to a city? That seems dangerous, even for a 60-year-old man with a heart of gold like Cleveland Browns head coach Todd Monken. 

People forget that five different coaches turned down even the thought of coaching the Browns last offseason. Monken wasn’t the Browns’—or any other of the nine hiring teams’—first choice. Before Monken was a “gritty, gritty old fucker,” as Browns defensive tackle Maliek Collins aptly put this week, he was just an old first-year head coach who had called good offenses in the past. It took just a couple months of Monken having the top job in Cleveland to see that he is much, much more than that. 

Monken inherited an untenable quarterback room and a defense that had lost coordinator Jim Schwartz and superstar edge rusher Myles Garrett in the same offseason, yet the Browns are 6-4 with a chance to win the AFC North entering their bye this week. Quarterback Deshaun Watson, previously an abject failure in Cleveland, is playing his best football as a Brown partly because Monken is running the offense masterfully with a retooled offensive line and genuinely one of the six best skill groups in the league. But Watson has orchestrated fourth-quarter comebacks in all six of Cleveland’s wins this season, and regression comes for all teams that have records stuffed with one-score wins decided on final possessions. Also, the Monken-Watson-led Browns offense ranks 25th in EPA per drive and 22nd in success rate in full games. So why is it still so obvious that Monken has been a slam dunk success for Cleveland? Because the Browns’ vibes, influenced mostly by Watson, were in the depths of hell before Monken, and pretty much right away Monken knew he needed to fix them. A tall order considering Watson’s history. 

Watson served an 11-game league suspension in 2022 after more than two dozen women gave accounts of sexual misconduct by the quarterback during massage sessions. The suspension came shortly after the Browns traded three first-round picks to the Texans for Watson and signed him to an unprecedented, league-first-and-only fully guaranteed deal at $230 million over five years. After he returned from suspension, Browns fans booed him weekly and cheered when he got hurt. Watson took offense to more booing during an ugly preseason loss in August, and in line with his remarks following all of the allegations, his response took into account only his feelings, not anyone else’s. Watson lashed out because he’s still hurt after all these years. Not because of another injury, but maybe because he’s never taken any responsibility for his actions beyond a nothingburger suspension four years ago. Monken correctly diagnosed how to handle Watson after his bad presser and has gotten the best out of him since. I don’t think that's a coincidence or a pattern on their Lilith.

This clip from Monken’s press conference came after Watson’s most recent comeback, against the Texans in a game the Browns trailed 17-0 in the second quarter. It was the first time Watson had faced his former team since he’d been traded in 2022, and he threw for over 300 yards, rushed for almost 50 and a score, and got the win on a drive late in the fourth quarter. What Monken is getting out of Watson and five brand new starters on the offensive line, even with star power at receiver, tight end, and running back, is astonishing. Monken’s ability to hose down the Watson-led Browns dumpster fire in just a few months is rare human behavior for a gritty old football coach: unbridled compassion. It’s so rare that the goddamn Cleveland Browns are winning games they shouldn’t with a quarterback everyone hated and a coach no one wanted just a few months ago. Give Monken a key to the Browns facilities for as long as he’s willing, at least, and we’ll reconsider the city after the playoffs (?!). In the interim, we can place Monken at the top of the list of 32 new play callers in 2026. Speaking of, let’s introduce a fresh set piece: My biggest mini-meter for TOM’s 10th birthday.

Mini-Meter: New Play Callers

Tier 1: Slam Dunks

  1. HC (Off.) Todd Monken, Browns: 9.4
  2. HC (Off.) Klint Kubiak, Raiders: 9.3
  3. OC Declan Doyle, Ravens: 8.9
  4. DC Raheem Morris, 49ers: 8.4

Call it homerism if you want, but Kubiak is only a hair behind Monken for top dog on this list. Kubs is easily the best Raiders coach and offensive play caller since Jon Gruden 1 over 20 years ago. Kubiak is still unlearning all the bad game management stuff buried under the roots of the Shanahan tree, but give him more pass catchers than banged-up Brock Bowers and more time with rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza, and the Raiders’ never-ending merry-go-round of rebuilds might finally be over. 

Doyle, a 30-year-old disciple of Chicago Bears head coach Ben Johnson, doesn’t break 9 like Monk and Kubs only because he’s probably gone after this year. Doyle would be the youngest head coach hired in NFL history, but he’s the only boy genius OC other than the guy at the top of the next tier, and multiple boy genius OCs get hired as head coaches every cycle. Doyle will be high on a lot of coaching candidate lists through the end of the season. How valuable is a brilliant offensive play caller underneath a head coach? Ask the Tampa Bay Buccaneers about Liam Coen now or the Detroit Lions about Ben Johnson when they’re ready to admit they’d rather have BJ than Dan Campbell even though DC is a great coach. 

Morris cracks this tier because he can be the old-head DC that every offensive head coach needs, à la Steve Spagnuolo to Andy Reid or Vance Joseph to Sean Payton or Todd Bowles to someone like Doyle eventually, I’d imagine. Morris is maximizing a bad 49ers defense with injuries and talent concerns at all three levels. 

Tier 2: Exceeding Expectations

  1. OC Drew Petzing, Lions: 7.5
  2. DC Patrick Graham, Steelers: 6.9
  3. DC Mike Rutenberg, Browns: 6.7
  4. HC (Off.) Mike McCarthy, Steelers: 6.66
  5. OC Matt Nagy, Giants: 6.5

Petzing (39 years old) is the other boy genius on this list. You could argue his job is easy with running back Jahmyr Gibbs and wide receiver Amon-Ra St. Brown, and you’d be right. But just because it’s easier for Petzing with Gibbs and Brown than it is for others with less star power doesn’t mean it’s a guarantee the offense will be good. Detroit ranks top five in EPA and success rate entering Week 11. Anything less would probably be a disappointment, but it isn’t, because of Petzing … which could create another Johnsonesque problem where Petzing walks for a better job and leaves Campbell to go to the well again for another OC, a vicious cycle that can plague any coach who doesn’t call offensive plays. 

McCarthy is making 42-year-old Aaron Rodgers’s last ride memorable because he’s probably the only man on the planet who could multitask calling plays and navigating a relationship with Rodgers. McCarthy also hired a clear winner in Graham, who was getting the best out of a bad Raiders unit before and is getting the best out of a better, older Steelers unit now. 

Rutenberg and Nagy crack this tier because I had bottom-of-the-barrel expectations for both of them, and I need to eat crow. Rutenberg, without Jim Schwartz or Myles Garrett, has Cleveland’s defense ranked 11th in EPA per drive. Incredible. Nagy, a failure in Chicago who wasn’t even calling plays in Kansas City, has had a revolving door at quarterback and running back, yet still has orchestrated a mostly functional offense week to week. Ridiculous. 

Tier 3: Showing Flashes

  1. DC Jonathan Gannon, Packers: 6.2
  2. DC Dennard Wilson, Giants: 6.1
  3. OC Brad Idzik, Panthers: 5.9
  4. HC (Def.) Jeff Hafley, Dolphins: 5.7

None of these four has shown enough consistency to get out of the flashy roller-coaster tier, but a lot can change in the colder football months. I will admit that part of the reason Hafley is this high is that his eyebrows strike fear into me through the television. I can’t imagine what it’s like making brow contact with him on the opposite sideline in the heat of battle. 

Tier 4: Backed the Wrong Horse

  1. DC Daronte Jones, Commanders: 4.9
  2. OC Frank Reich, Jets: 4.4

Washington Commanders head coach Dan Quinn may have avoided an in-season firing by beating the Giants on Thursday Night Football last week, but DQ clearly isn’t going to last much longer in Washington. I’d say the same about New York Jets head coach Aaron Glenn, but every week he’s still employed with the Jets, the longer I think they are enjoying the bit. Is there still a chance that Jones or Reich will get interim titles this year? Sure. But it won’t matter much at this point.

Tier 5: Not Good Enough (Yet?)

  1. HC (Def.) Jesse Minter, Ravens: 3.7
  2. OC Brian Fleury, Seahawks: 3.4
  3. HC (Off.) Mike LaFleur, Cardinals: 3.1

Minter is still sitting comfortably in the Glenn Zone; he’s a mediocre defensive play-calling head coach who will live and die by his QB and OC. Minter’s best QB, Lamar Jackson, might not ever play for the Ravens again (more on that deeper down in TOM’s Gut), and his next-best QB, 33-year-old Jacoby Brissett, stinks out loud. And, of course, Doyle, Minter’s OC, is just a boy genius waiting to break out. 

LaFleur and Fleury both call offensive plays, so they’re ineligible for the Glenn Zone, but neither has shown enough on offense to even break into the Flashes tier. Some of that is out of their control; you’re guilty until proven innocent if you call offensive plays in the NFL. Could the offensive version of the Glenn Zone be LaFleur? It’s too early to say, but email me at takeometer@spotify.com if you have ideas for an offensive counterpart to the GZ. Multiple Meter Writers have pitched ideas like KOC Corner, but we need to keep the brainstorm going. 

Tier 6: Scapegoats in Line for the Slaughter

  1. DC Nick Rallis, Cardinals: 1.9
  2. OC Tommy Rees, Falcons: 1.8
  3. OC Zac Robinson, Buccaneers: 1.7
  4. OC Bobby Slowik, Dolphins: 1.7
  5. OC David Blough, Commanders: 1.5
  6. OC Sean Mannion, Eagles: 1.5
  7. DC Jim Leonhard, Bills: 1.0
  8. HC (Def.) Robert Saleh, Titans: 0.8

Maybe these guys won't get fired before next season, but they’re first in line if things don’t improve ASAP. Atlanta Falcons head coach Kevin Stefanski, who won two Coach of the Year awards while calling plays for the Browns in 2020 and 2023, will take over play calling from Rees when he’s pressured to play that card. LaFleur can fit Rallis under the bus easily if Arizona’s brass needs blood for LaFleur to continue in 2027. The same goes for Leonhard under Buffalo Bills head coach Joe Brady. The two former Pro Football Focus guys, Robinson and Slowik, are off to slow starts on their second stints as offensive play callers in the NFL. The two former bad backup quarterbacks, Blough and Mannion, look like bad backup quarterbacks calling plays. Saleh is hanging by a frickin’ thread because he has two disposable bodies, OC Brian Daboll (coming up soon) and QB Cam Ward, to tuck under the bus like presents under a Douglas fir. Merry Christmas, Rob, you filthy animal.

 Tier 7: Blood Sacrifices

  1. OC Brian Daboll, Titans: 0.6
  2. DC Rob Leonard, Raiders: 0.2
  3. DC Christian Parker, Cowboys: 0.1
  4. OC Davis Webb, Broncos: 0.01
  5. HC (Def.) Aaron Glenn, Jets: 0.0
  6. OC Mike McDaniel, Dolphins: –1.0

Saleh will take Daboll’s head if the season continues to go the way it's going. If the government can ground planes, it can arrest Leonard and Parker for their football crimes. There aren’t two units in the sport that look more juiceless or useless than what Leonard and Parker are leading out of the tunnel on Sundays. Sean Payton already relieved Webb of play calling weeks ago, so the hair of a promised genius is already boiling in the cauldron in my closet. Glenn will be thrown in the pot whole eventually, and Mike McDaniel will be—AAHHH. HELP. WHAT’S HAPPENING?! 

[McDaniel knocked AG unconscious for a spell and is now stirring the pot with a robed, masked figure in a dark room lit bright blue only in the brief moments when McD hits his disposable vape pen.]

Celeb Shot: The Chargers should run it back with Mike McDaniel in 2027.

No, it’s not Tom Cruise in Eyes Wide Shut. It’s LJ, a dad-aged Chargers fan, Vandy grad, and Meter Writer. He texted me a great hook: What was Kyle Shanahan’s record after his first eight weeks in San Francisco? I guessed 1-7 because he asked during the Chargers’ first win of the season against the Ravens on Monday night, but the answer is 0-8 and then 0-9 the following week. How do you like them apples? 

LJ followed up his hook with a gut punch that moved my core and dropped my jaw: Bring back McDaniel and draft Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. Should it happen? Probably not, considering this is arguably the worst season for a football team versus expectations this century, and the Bolts beat career backup Jacoby Brissett and Minter’s Ravens. Could it happen? Maybe! Worse offensive play callers have gotten second chances, and Smith is the first receiver to genuinely remind me of Julio Jones when he was last a Falcon. Is it a perfect take to debut a TOM-first Meter Writer Celeb Shot? Absolutely. I can’t soberly condone rerolling the dice with McDaniel after such a disastrous start to the year, but could I have a little fun entertaining this bit for a few puffs off the magic dragon? 

[Cough. Cough. AG wakes up in a purple haze to realize McDaniel didn’t hit him at all and the vape wasn’t CBD. AG quickly remembers now he, McD, and LJ were passing the penjamin around before they got the blood ritual stew going.]

The Gut: The Ravens want to move on from Lamar Jackson.

OK, let’s snap back to harsh reality. Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson could miss the rest of the season with a thumb injury, and like I teased before, some believe Jackson has played his last snap in Baltimore. Jackson’s contract with the Ravens includes an $84 million cap hit in 2027 and a $42 million hit in 2028 because of void years, so next year he’ll be 30 years old, coming off a potentially season-ending injury to his throwing hand, and playing on a one-year, $84 million contract. There’s a world where Jackson plays out his contract in Baltimore with Minter, Doyle, 32-year-old Derrick Henry, and chronic clutch fumbler Zay Flowers and wins a Super Bowl in February 2028. There’s also a world where Ravens ownership doesn’t believe in miracles or fairy tales and is instead considering Jackson’s age and injuries, the state of the roster, Minter’s and Doyle’s unknown future together, and the –$51 million in projected cap space in 2027. In the latter world, I’d expect stories like the several we’ve seen this week hinting at Jackson’s potential availability in the offseason to ramp up as the season progresses. Because Lamar famously doesn’t have an agent and negotiated a no-trade clause in his contract, y’all better get your popcorn ready. My gut says the Ravens want out, but this time, they don’t have the leverage of the rest of the cartel over Jackson. 

J.J. Watt should be fined and Kevin Stefanski suspended.

I don’t know if it’s fish, but this right here STINKS, dog. 

Watch the clip above if you haven’t already. It’s Hall of Fame defensive end and CBS color commentator J.J. Watt undressing the Falcons organization on live television. He shows the world that Atlanta right tackle Jawaan Taylor is tipping the run-pass decisions pre-snap with his stance IN WEEK 10 OF THE NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE. Nothing is right about this, but two things are glaringly wrong: 

  1. The rule is this: You spot a man’s tell, you don’t say a(n effing) word. That’s Mike McDermott (Matt Damon) in Rounders. McDermott, a man convinced that degenerate gambling is his destiny because he’s good with numbers, knows you don’t give away a man’s tell. And if you do, you do it at the apex of the movie across from Teddy KGB (John Malkovich) while chasing an arc and three stacks of high society. Maybe it’s an apples-to-oranges comparison because Watt is paid to make great TV, and this was great TV, but Watt still gave away Taylor’s tell way too early in the movie. 
  2. Watt has the same tape as the Falcons. If Watt can spot this prepping for the game in a week, head coach Kevin Stefanski should have nipped this in the bud with Taylor months ago. This is not a tenth as embarrassing for Taylor as it is for Stefanski and Co. 

The Steelers should start Mason Rudolph in 2027.

The Sunday Night Football announce team, Mike Tirico and Cris Collinsworth, didn’t reveal that Cincinnati Bengals head coach Zac Taylor tips his calls or anything on Watt’s level, but when Collinsworth did throw in a line at the end of the Pittsburgh Steelers’ embarrassing blowout loss to the Bengals saying that McCarthy would be fine to “roll out” 32-year-old Mason Rudolph as the starter in 2027, it was an unnecessary jump scare for Steelers faithful. Rudolph isn’t even under contract next year, and a new deal for him to start would cost $20 million or more, which would then be a much graver error than Watt’s, Stefanski’s, or Taylor’s.

Take II: Kirk Cousins makes the Vikings a legit NFC contender.

I’m back (like the above version of the Terminator after he’s already survived multiple pipe bombs, a car explosion, and a buffet of shotgun pumps to the back, chest, and head), and I’ll keep coming back until Minnesota Vikings head coach Kevin O’Connell crushes me flat in an NFC conference title game with 38-year-old Kirk Cousins at the helm. In my red robot eye, KOC and Kirko are still riding defensive coordinator Brian Flores’s coattails, and better teams—like the 49ers, whom they play in Mexico City on Sunday night—will shut down the offense enough to survive Flores’s assault in the playoffs. Minnesota converted a third-and-23, third-and-15, and third-and-12 on their three touchdown drives against Green Bay. I’m going to tip my cap and move forward, trusting that kind of luck will even out, if not disappear entirely against stiffer competition in the winter.

Parker Washington is WR8.

I’ll admit it. I’m a little horny for Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Parker Washington. He’s my type of receiver: small, but rocked up and tough as nails with elite hands, ball skills, and YAC ability. Like if ARSB and Steve Smith Sr. had a baby just for me. Ja’Marr Chase, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Justin Jefferson, Puka Nacua, St. Brown, Nico Collins, and CeeDee Lamb are all ahead of Washington for me, but the list stops there. Debate a wall. 

Austin Gayle
Austin Gayle
Austin Gayle is writing a weekly column, the Take-O-Meter. He was a longtime *Oakland* Raiders season-ticket holder with his dad, so he still thinks about Derek Carr’s leg every Christmas, the Tuck Rule every year he gets older, Brock Bowers every morning, and Klint Kubiak every night. Fernando Mendoza is with Gayle always, an omnipresent figure suited helmet-to-cleat, always ready to go.

Keep Exploring

Latest in NFL