
Every week this NFL season, we will break down the highs and lows—and everything in between—from the most recent slate of pro football. This week, Kirk Cousins returned to the Vikings, the NFC North continued to surge, the Texans threw yet another game away, and much more. Welcome to Winners and Losers.
Winner: Kirk Cousins’s Vikings Return
All season, I’ve been wondering what the Vikings would look like if they had even just an average starting quarterback. I finally received an answer on Sunday, and it was … maybe the best team in the NFC! Kirk Cousins returned to the Vikings via trade on Tuesday, and on Sunday he led Minnesota past a red-hot Green Bay team in a 30-10 win. And the game never felt particularly close.
Never before has it been this exciting to watch a decidedly average offense. Cousins finished with a pedestrian 207 passing yards on 31 attempts, but Minnesota’s offense finally looked like it wasn’t actively working against its league-best defense. When Cousins was helped by short fields—Minnesota had four possessions that began in Green Bay territory—he paid it off with three drives that ended in field goals, and the fourth was the final drive of the game. That alone was a relief for the Vikings, who couldn’t count on previous starting quarterbacks Kyler Murray or Carson Wentz not to waste opportunities or turn the ball over themselves.
Head coach Kevin O’Connell hasn’t earned back his reputation as a supposed quarterback whisperer just yet, but the accusations of him being an outright fraud can rest for a week. Minnesota’s offense was more cohesive on Sunday, and that’s due directly to how much better Cousins fits this system than any of Minnesota’s other options. Sunday was the first time in the last three weeks that the Vikings rushed for over 100 yards, and the first time they’ve had 10 under-center dropbacks since their Week 3 game against the Buccaneers. With Cousins back, O’Connell can finally call the offense as it's designed—without trying to reverse engineer his scheme to fit a shotgun-heavy quarterback like Murray or an unreliable one like Wentz.
Things were still ugly for this unit at times on Sunday, but ugly is an upgrade from inoperable. Minnesota has now swept the season series against the Packers, has a 90 percent chance of making the playoffs, and controls its destiny in the NFC North race. If they win the division and stay in the race for the top seed in the conference, the trade for Cousins will be one of the most consequential quarterback moves in modern history. Imagine that! —Diante Lee
Winner: The NFC North Playoff Picture
When Week 9 ended, the Vikings had a non-viable offense and two borderline unplayable quarterbacks. The Packers had the most dangerous deep-ball game in the league. The Lions had a defense that seemed like it could finally complement their high-flying offense. And the Bears looked like they could win in every way imaginable.
What a difference six days, a quarterback trade, and a devastating non-contact injury have made to the balance of power in the NFC North.
The Vikings are back on top of the division standings, buoyed by the emotional return of Cousins and a dominant defensive performance against Green Bay, whose fragile, one-dimensional offense was exposed by the blitz-heavy Vikings. The Lions, meanwhile, won big in Munich—extending their win streak to five games—behind yet another lights-out offensive performance from Jared Goff and Co. But they’ll return home to major questions about the state of their defense after pass rusher Aidan Hutchinson suffered what is believed to be a season-ending knee injury. The Bears watched all this divisional drama unfold from home during their bye week.
This is by far the best division in football, and now that the trade deadline is in the rearview mirror, our full attention turns to the playoff race. And there might be no more interesting question over the final eight weeks of the season than this: Can all four NFC North teams make the postseason? A single division has never sent all four teams to the playoffs in the Super Bowl era, and the league’s rule that automatically gives a playoff spot to each division winner makes the math especially challenging. But it’s not impossible! And thanks to the complete shittiness of the NFC South and NFC East, which are all but guaranteed to only get one team into the playoff field, this could finally be the year it happens.
The North has three 7-2 teams (Minnesota, Detroit, Chicago), and each of them has a better than 80 percent chance of making the playoffs, according to The New York Times’ playoff simulator. The 6-4 Packers, meanwhile, still have a 42 percent chance of getting a spot. Green Bay fans should find themselves rooting against the Rams and Seahawks, the current top wild-card contenders, the rest of the way. And if the Packers can win on the road in L.A. on Thanksgiving Eve, a four-team NFC North playoff field just might become a reality. –Lindsay Jones
Loser: Fernando Mendoza’s First NFL Start
The best-case scenario for rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza’s first career NFL start—which came against the Seahawks and defensive-minded head coach Mike Macdonald—was close to what we got during Mendoza’s first two possessions. He completed 8-of-9 passes for 55 yards and scrambled for two first downs and a touchdown on third-and-goal from the 10-yard line. His pocket management and mobility were both spectacular too—but the wheels came off quickly.
The worst-case scenario for Mendoza’s debut was exactly what we got after those first two drives. Mendoza completed just 9-of-20 passes for 88 yards and took six sacks. Losing star tight end Brock Bowers to an ankle injury on the fifth play of the game didn’t help, but Mendoza’s pocket management (and confidence) simply fell through the floor after the opening script. He took multiple hits and sacks from unblocked defenders, seemingly without even seeing them before getting earholed. To start the second half, the Raiders had five straight three-and-outs that culminated in –17 yards. Macdonald was facing off against his former offensive coordinator and current Raiders head coach Klint Kubiak and had him in a vice grip throughout the last 30 minutes of Seattle’s 21-13 win.
In every case, Kubiak and Mendoza were going to experience growing pains together, especially going up against a defense as vaunted as the Seahawks’. But another Bowers injury on top of Sunday’s second-half ass-whooping offered up a tall order of settle-down juice to Raiders fans who were rocking their Mendoza jerseys for the first time on Sunday. —Austin Gayle
Winner: Joe Burrow’s Big Night
This season’s MVP race has a new entrant: Joe Burrow.
Burrow and the Bengals’ passing game made a statement against the Steelers, with the quarterback throwing for 409 yards and four touchdowns in a 38-18 Sunday night victory. Burrow built up a 24-3 lead before halftime and spent most of the fourth quarter on the bench, basking in one of the best prime-time performances of his career. He’s been on fire all season, with four different four-touchdown games, and he’s currently on pace for the third 5,000-yard, 50-touchdown season in NFL history. He’s now the betting favorite to win MVP on FanDuel, and he’d certainly win the award if he keeps up this pace, just as Peyton Manning and Patrick Mahomes did when they had 5,000/50 seasons.
After three consecutive seasons of missing the playoffs, the Bengals have been stuck on the periphery of teams we should care about. Even as Cincinnati raced out to a 6-2 start in the first half of the year, their Week 3 loss to the Steelers and close calls against the Dolphins and Titans felt like reasons to dismiss them as the same old Bengals. No matter how many yards they racked up and how many points they scored, there was just no way to trust this defense or the team’s health enough to call them real contenders.
But maybe this is the year that Burrow and his supporting cast actually stay healthy. The Bengals also have an extremely easy remaining schedule—matching up against teams like the Commanders, Saints, Panthers, Colts, and Browns. There’s a legitimate chance that the Bengals could win 13 or more games, and maybe even contend for the top seed in the AFC. If that’s the case, and if Burrow stays this hot, he’ll be an MVP lock and Cincinnati will look like championship front-runners.
In a year where the Bengals tried to add talent to their defense and incorporate more of the Shanahan-McVay under-center run game, neither are the reasons why Cincinnati looks elite again. They’re winning the same way they always have—and it’s working because they’re better at it than they’ve ever been. —Lee
Loser: Houston’s Postseason Chances
Houston has made a habit of starting a season off terribly, then rallying and entering the playoffs as one of the hottest teams. Now, though, they’ve tested fate one too many times. Sunday’s 27-24 loss to the Browns makes their playoff hopes a real long shot.
Houston’s game was a reflection of their season. They raced out to a 17-0 lead in the first half thanks to a near-perfect start from quarterback C.J. Stroud. Stroud went into halftime with a 121.5 passer rating, and Houston should have been able to ride the momentum of his hot start to a win. But the defense unraveled—as they’ve done a number of times this year—and the offense ran out of answers against Cleveland's man coverage. By the end of the game, the Browns just looked like the better team. There’s an irony in this outcome for me, because all season I’ve been dismissive of Cleveland due to their inexperience and poor quarterback play. But the Browns have shown us an ability to make adjustments and close out games with wins, while Houston hasn’t. For a Texans team that’s had legitimate Super Bowl aspirations for the last two years, there’s no excuse for how this game ended—or the games against the Giants, Colts and Cowboys earlier in the year.
If this team had simply won the games they were supposed to, they wouldn’t have their backs against the wall with half the season still remaining. But at 3-6, the Athletic’s NFL Simulator had Houston’s playoff chances at just 12 percent directly after their loss—and the simulator accounts for how easy most of their remaining slate is. Just to sneak in as the sixth or seventh seed in the AFC, the Texans would have to win two of their three games against the Steelers, Jaguars, and Packers. How can we trust the Texans to do that given their uneven play?
At some point, Houston has to give us a different story to tell. They’ve had the talent, the continuity and a friendly enough schedule to establish themselves as a legitimate contending team, but instead they’ve veered in the opposite direction. As Hall of Fame coach Bill Parcells said, “You are what your record says you are.” Right now, the Texans’ tells us they’re unserious. —Lee
Winner: Brock Purdy’s Highlight Reel
There are a couple plays from Week 10 that I’ll be watching on repeat. Like Travis Hunter’s interception:
And this touchdown throw by Miami receiver Malik Washington (!!):
And then there’s this 74-yard touchdown pass from Brock Purdy to Christian McCaffrey in the 49ers’ 46-40 win against Dallas:
This one stands out for a few reasons. First, it was the longest touchdown catch of McCaffrey’s career —not bad for a 30-year-old running back. Next, go back and watch Purdy’s mobility here. He dodged the Cowboys’ rush, escaped the pocket, and rather than safely scampering out of bounds, he reset his feet behind the line of scrimmage and threw across his body to hit McCaffrey. That’s a savvy play and an aggressive throw by a quarterback who led all quarterbacks in expected points added per dropback in Week 10. Purdy did not have a turnover on Sunday against the Cowboys, and while he was sacked five times, he made Dallas pay for their aggression, posting a perfect passer rating of 158.3 when the Cowboys sent five or more rushers.
And speaking of the Cowboys, they sent a blitz on this third down. The 49ers anticipated the extra rushers, and McCaffrey initially stayed in to block. As Purdy turned this play into a scramble drill, McCaffrey got himself out of traffic and was wide open in the middle of the field. No Cowboys defender even had a chance once Purdy looked McCaffrey’s way. McCaffrey would score twice more in the game, on a 16-yard run and on a 66-yard catch-and-run when the 49ers managed to get him one-on-one against 37-year-old edge rusher Von Miller. Miller is a future Hall of Famer, but at this point in his career, it is malpractice that the Cowboys are asking him to drop into coverage.
Dallas’s defense has been a disaster all year, but Sunday marked a new low. By defensive EPA, the Cowboys’ performance against the 49ers was the single worst game of the season. They allowed 584 yards, a whopping 9.4 yards per play—the most by any offense in a game this season. Dallas can’t cover, they can’t tackle, and on Sunday, they added to Purdy’s MVP resume. –Jones
Winner: The Chiefs’ Post-Trade Deadline Passing Game
Now that was a vintage Patrick Mahomes performance.
The Chiefs quarterback threw for 348 yards and five touchdowns in a 35-13 win over the Atlanta Falcons. He was nearly perfect: no turnovers, and just two sacks despite being pressured 19 times (tied for the most of any QB in Week 10). And this is the most exciting stat for people who have watched the Chiefs dink-and-dunk their way through the last few seasons: Mahomes had seven completions of at least 20 yards against Atlanta. It’s only the second time since 2022 that he’s had that many 20-plus-yard passing plays in a game.
Eight Chiefs caught at least one pass from Mahomes on Sunday, and three receivers—Josh Downs, Cyrus Allen, and Andrew Armstrong—each caught their first Kansas City touchdowns. That rookies Allen and Armstrong both scored made for a nice story, and it’s a sign that Mahomes is starting to trust teammates not named Travis Kelce. But it’s this absolute beauty of a touchdown to Downs that should have the rest of the AFC on alert.
Downs just arrived in Kansas City a few days ago after the Chiefs traded fourth- and fifth-round picks to acquire him from the Indianapolis Colts. Downs is known for his speed and route-running ability, and the Chiefs have desperately needed a receiving option who can consistently get open and create mismatches downfield. Xavier Worthy has speed, but he hasn’t developed as a route runner. Rashee Rice is a trusted target in the middle of the field, but he doesn’t have the speed to consistently get much separation. Downs immediately looks like he’ll be able to give the Chiefs’ receiving corps the diversity of skill set and depth it had been missing.
Earlier this season, the Chiefs looked like a team that was going to be overly dependent on Kenneth Walker III and the run game. And in recent weeks, as good Denver and Seattle defenses shut down Walker and stifled the Chiefs in the red zone, it looked like the Chiefs might not have the ability to become multi-dimensional. After Sunday, those concerns feel like history. –Jones
Loser: The Patriots in Germany
Patriots quarterback Drake Maye orchestrated an 11-play, 60-yard drive that ended with a field goal on the team’s opening possession against the Lions on Sunday morning in Germany, going 3-for-4 for 48 yards and an 11-yard scramble. But Maye didn’t play another down after that drive. When Lions edge defender Aidan Hutchinson sacked Maye from behind on third-and-goal before the Andy Borregales field goal, Maye hobbled off the field and to the locker room. He was ruled out soon after with an ankle injury. The Lions put their foot on the gas from there and won the game 35-10, and Pats fans tweeted to cope with the ordeal.

It’s so far unclear exactly what injury Maye suffered and how long he may be out as a result. Wide receiver A.J. Brown also went down with a hamstring injury in this game, and Brown has already missed multiple games this season with an ankle injury that he suffered in Week 1. With or without the physical issues, he’s been a major disappointment for New England this season. And he looks as disinterested in catching the football as he did last year with the Philadelphia Eagles. Brown left the locker room with a limp and declined to speak to reporters on his way out, per the Boston Herald’s Andrew Callahan. But Brown playing like shit and getting hurt is almost old news for Pats fans; the new news with Maye is a lot worse.
Maye is bound to miss time. Without him, the Patriots (5-5) could have to start Tommy Devito against the Chargers, Bills, Vikings, and Chiefs following their Week 11 bye. And describing Maye’s injury after the game, Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel said the QB “couldn't function, couldn't play, couldn't run, couldn't do whatever he needed to do to play quarterback,” which is why he was ruled out quickly. New England isn’t a playoff team if Maye can’t function, and Vrabel is running out of motivational things to say to the team. That’s got to be one long flight back from Germany. —Gayle

