The Ringer
Discover
anything

Plain English With Derek Thompson

The Midterms and the End of the Boomer Political Era

The Midterms and the End of the Boomer Political Era
The Midterms and the End of Boomer Politics
Watch episode

About the episode

Well, it’s midterm day in America, and on my mind are three huge questions for tonight. No. 1: How much water is in the blue wave? No. 2: Everyone’s talking about the cost of living, inflation, and affordability, but who actually wants to do something about it? And no. 3: Will this election finally be the beginning of the end of boomer politics?

To answer these questions and more, Derek joins forces with political journalist and podcaster Saagar Enjeti. Together, they break down potential midterm outcomes, the state of the GOP, ethics in Washington, and the future of millennial politics in America.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel here.

If you have questions, observations, or ideas for future episodes, email us at PlainEnglish@Spotify.com.

 

 

In the following excerpt, Derek and Saagar Enjeti discuss the Michigan Senate race and how things are looking for the GOP.

Derek Thompson: So let’s start with a quick hit in the news at the moment. Democratic runner-up in Michigan, Haley Stevens, just endorsed the Republican, Mike Rogers. What’s going on here, man?

Saagar Enjeti: Wow. Yeah, I said it on the show today, all-time messy woman. I hate to be too sexist here, but she’s a fascinating character. I mean, there’s so much going on with that, right? She is somebody who in the hours before had reportedly said she was going to vote for El-Sayed. The night before, she’s on the phone with Jamie Raskin. She says, “I’m backing El-Sayed.” The morning of, she appears to have had some sort of crisis of confidence or something, and she calls Mike Rogers and she says, “Can I go to church with you?” Even then, she’s not voting for Mike Rogers. And then she just comes out in the car video and she’s like, “Yeah, that’s who I’m voting for.” I mean, there’s so much, I guess, that could be said. We could do the Israel angle of it all, which is honestly kind of shocking. Her own fiancé, who himself is interesting character, Mr. Jason Turkish, who she only apparently recently met only in the last several months or so, this romance, but he comes out, and apparently he’s been very influential and evolving her thinking. A lot of this goes back to this RebellionPAC ad, which was released by Cenk Uygur. By the way, it never actually ran on the airwaves, just purely on Twitter.

So all of this leads to her just basically coming out and saying, “Because he hurt my feelings and disinvited me from this event, I’m going to endorse Mike Rogers,” which is crazy. I mean, it is objectively crazy. She said he’s a MAGA mouthpiece and a rubber stamp for Donald Trump. And this morning, or this afternoon, I’m reading that she just did a sit-down interview at 11:00 p.m. on her fiancé‘s couch with Olivia Reingold over at The Free Press, and she’s like, “Well, maybe Mike can be like Lisa Murkowski.” And I’m like, “Well, Mike’s actually been in the Congress for a long time, honestly, almost since I was alive, and he’s pretty much not been that way. So maybe you’re dreaming a little bit differently.”

Thompson: Yeah. If Mike Rogers wins, obviously this is going to be seen as absolutely seismic, especially if the Democrats underperform their polling. If El-Sayed wins, do you think we’re going to be talking about this in two weeks? Does this uncover something that’s latent in the Democratic Party that’s going to have to be dealt with?

Enjeti: Well, you can speak more to this, actually, because the teed-up conversation for Abdul … There are various Abdul scenarios. So the day you and I are speaking, obviously, New York Times/Siena has Abdul up by 11. That would be actually shocking, shocking, overperforming, Gretchen Whitmer levels of success. That’s one where the DSA and, let’s say, the left flank can say, “See, we told you so.”

Let’s say he underperforms, and it’s a squeaker, similar to his primary victory. Well, the actual conversation that was set up before all of this was a, “Well, see, your Israel stance and your combativeness within the Democratic Party…” This has now made it so that if he does lose or if it’s a squeaker, underperforms, the conversation is about her, even though, honestly, the vast majority of the votes in Michigan have already been cast, which is ironic.

But if you look to some of the way that the intraparty discussion of it all was going to be discussed, I would say we’re not going to talk about it if it’s a blowout, like let’s say if it is like 10, 8 points, something like that. But if Abdul underperforms, let’s say, by a point or 2.5, something like that, then yeah, I actually do think we will be discussing it because there will be the battle of the narratives about why he was able to underperform.

The way I would look at it is kind of like the J.D. Vance vote in 2022. I’m sure you remember this, where there was a lot of discussion where he underperformed Donald Trump in the state. And so there was a factional intraparty GOP fight over, is he actually a strong candidate? He says he’s the future. The guy barely wins Ohio by six. Trump previously won it by eight the last time around. So how can you say that you have any sort of strength? But Haley Stevens did Abdul the biggest favor she ever could, honestly. He raised millions of dollars. She will be the primary rhetorical discussion point around this election. And to the extent he has any flaws, she took them all away from him in the national media conversation. It’s wild.

Thompson: I’m glad you ended there. That’s exactly what I think. Look, if El-Sayed loses, then he loses, period. If he wins and he underperforms, the conversation around underperformance now is entirely muddied by the Stevens endorsement, because the centrists who want to say, “Ah, he underperformed because he’s a progressive,” lose a certain amount of juice in that argument because his opponent just endorsed his opponent. And then if he overperforms, oh my God, going into 2028, the number of progressive, I think, groups that are going to look at him as a potential presidential nominee are just going to feel even more bolstered that this guy is impregnable. More broadly, on a scale of 1 to 10, how panicked are Republicans right now?

Enjeti: Well, so panic is not … It depends on the race. So Texas, I’m 10 out of 10. I grew up in Texas. I’ve got good sources in Texas GOP. It’s a real problem right now. I mean, my best people are telling me Talarico is basically a lock now. I mean, they could play that over, and I could look like a complete fool if it doesn’t, but I’m just repeating what they tell me. I am also, again, everybody I speak to is really the same stuff that they’re leaking to all the national political reporters is we have real Trump problems all the way down the ballot.

There’s actually a great story today, which mimics a lot of what I’ve heard from people who will be willing to speak candidly or off the record, which is about Trump’s role himself. So if we look down the list, North Carolina, which looks like a genuine lock for Cooper, well, Thom Tillis, I mean, Trump forced him out of the party. And Tillis, remember, had an impressive victory last time around whenever he was on the ballot. I remember covering that race.

Let’s continue. South Carolina, who was supposed to be interim Senator Darline Graham, he says, “Oh, no, Darline, you’re going to be the nominee,” forces her barely over the line in the Republican primary, which was actually a big field. A real South Carolina GOP politician has absolutely no problems in this race. Now they’re having to spend millions of dollars.

Okay, let’s keep going. So Texas, obviously John Cornyn. And this is the thing too. If Trump wanted to go all in on Paxton, whatever. He could have done that early. He flirted all the way up until the line after the runoff. Will they? Won’t they? Will they? He’s going to endorse Paxton. He’s not. Eventually comes out, pushes Paxton over the edge, but he’s fully aware of all of Paxton’s flaws. The problem is by not picking him early and clearing the field with Cornyn is the NRSC spent millions of dollars against Ken Paxton, and so it’s very hard for them then to come in to try to save him. Paxton had to rely on all this outside MAGA Inc. spending after all these Republican negative ads are against him. So demoralized Republicans, the kind of country club style demographic is definitely shifting away from Ken Paxton. From what I’ve heard there, Talarico, I mean, he’s a unique, interesting candidate kind of in his own way, but Texas itself currently trending towards that direction.

So this is Donald … Oh, J.D., actually. I mean, this is one where by picking J.D. as his nominee for the vice president, he sets up for this election now in the United States Senate where Sherrod Brown, I mean, look, whatever you want to say about that guy, that guy always overperforms where the normal Democrat does in the state. I mean, this is a genuine union, anti-free-trade guy. He wrote whole books about steel tariffs. He’s undeniable, if you want to say it, on the policy question, and then he’s going to ride that wave here.

So there’s multiple races here where Trump’s own fingerprints are all over this thing. So to the extent they’re panicked, too, it’s like this is just Trump’s party. You can’t really say that Donald Trump, “Oh, this is a rebuke,” or “If they had clung to Trump better.” It’s like, no. I mean, he picked the nominees, these are his people, something he’s usually very, very proud of, and things are not looking good for him right now.

This excerpt has been edited and condensed.

Host: Derek Thompson
Guest: Saagar Enjeti
Producer: Devon Baroldi
Additional Production Support: Ben Glicksman